Price Controls Make A Statement About Society

Economics has a reputation for being a “dismal science” in part because highlights the ways in which various utopian schemes are impractical or impossible (Sandra Peart and David Levy point out that it’s also because some of the early classical economists made “ radical claims about the equality of all men ,” but that’s not my focus here).  The last refuge of the interventionist defeated at every turn by the laws of supply and demand is to say that while his or her program might have unintended consequences, it “makes a statement about the kind of society we live in.”

Interventions make statements, to be sure, but they aren’t statements to be proud of.  In the case of various forms of interference with the market–minimum wages, redistribution, price controls, immigration restrictions, and so on—the messages are unmistakable and unflattering.

Consider price controls, which legislate maximum prices that suppliers can charge for rental apartments or “essential” supplies after natural disasters. Basic microeconomics shows how price controls create shortages . What kinds of messages do price controls send about the kind of society in which we live?

They say that our society doesn’t know the lessons economics has to teach.  Price controls create shortages, and they also drive a wedge between the price of a good or service and what people are willing to pay or accept.  Suppose someone is willing to pay $10 for a gallon of gas after a storm but is only allowed to pay $2 in cash.  If he values his time at $8 per hour, he will be willing to pay with $2 in cash and an hour of time spent standing in line.  The cruel irony of this is that the entire difference between the legal maximum price and the price people are willing to pay for every gallon that is supplied will evaporate as people stand in line for gas.  Everyone is unambiguously worse off relative to where they would be without price controls.

They say that our society is elitist.  Price controls inflict positive harm on precisely the people we wish to help, and for what?  So that people removed from the situation can feel good about themselves?  Excusing others’ suffering in the name of your ideals is neither virtuous nor compassionate.  The Foundation for Economic Education’s Sheldon Richman once said that advocating policies when you don’t understand their unintended consequences is “ the intellectual equivalent of drunk driving .”   If you’re advocating price controls and don’t understand what the laws of supply and demand have to say about your proposal, you aren’t courageous or compassionate.  You’re dangerous.

A Utopian Socety - News


Price Controls Make A Statement About Society
Price Controls Make A Statement About Society

Economics has a reputation for being a “dismal science” in part because highlights the ways in which various utopian schemes are impractical or impossible (Sandra Peart and David Levy point out that it's also because some of the early



Waggoner on the promise of utopia

Last year, the Weekend of Chamber Music partnered with the Catskill Art Society for a project that lauded the existence of wallpaper murals found within the walls of Livingston Manor Central School. Designed in 1834 in France,



Serkis and Wyatt Plotting Mo-Cap 'Animal Farm' Adaptation

Orwell's allegorical dress-down of Stalinism, centering on a group of farm animals whose utopian society is undone by scheming and corruption, has thus far yielded two feature-length films, the most recent of which was a 1999 made-for-TV effort



'Therapeutic abortion' seeks to create 'eugenic utopia': Vatican newspaper

The root of such neo-Malthusian movements was not the achievement of freedom of individual choice but a eugenic utopia.” Galeotti concludes that a “common thread” ties 18th century norms, so despicable to modern society, with the modern ideology so



How can the sterilized ever be compensated?

More than 27 states joined the shameful decades-long utopian campaign. But only one state, North Carolina, is now considering a massive plan of financial reparations to its surviving victims. Just how much North Carolina should pay is now the subject




A Utopian Socety - Bookshelf

A Christmas carol in prose, being a ghost story of Christmas

A Christmas carol in prose, being a ghost story of Christmas

A CHEISTMAS CAROL. STAVE ONE. HURLEY'S GHOST. Marley was dead : to begin with. There is no doubt whatever about that. The register of his burial was signed ...

A streetcar named desire

A streetcar named desire

This classic 20th century play presents themes of survival, death, sexual passion, madness and the haunting legacy of the past. 13 parts: 7 male, 6 female.Set ...

A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's court

A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's court

Hank Morgan finds himself transported back to England's Dark Ages -- where he is immediately captured and sentenced to death at Camelot.

A People's History of the United States

A People's History of the United States

Presents the history of the United States from the point of view of those who were exploited in the name of American progress.

A Long Way Gone, Memoirs of a Boy Soldier

A Long Way Gone, Memoirs of a Boy Soldier

In a heart-wrenching, candid autobiography, a human rights activist offers a firsthand account of war from the perspective of a former child soldier, detailing ...

Daily Article Directory


Books by Diane Tessman
Earth Changes Bible: A Personal Guide to the Coming Global Transformation ... and catastrophes to plague the planet before a Utopian socety can be born. ...

Auroville - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Auroville will be a site of material and spiritual researches for a living ... At its centre, a 70 cm crystal ball in a gold mount and glow with a single ray ...

How Modern Liberals Think! Now here's a video liberals will ...
Now here's a video liberals will turn off after the first three ... His Utopian socety in which there is no greed,no racism,sexism,no inequality,no poverty,and no unhappiness. ...

Animals and Human Society: Changing Perspectives ...
Animals and Societybrings together a broad range of contributions from those ... importance of of animals in socety from social, historical and cross-cultural ...

Animals and Human Society in eBooks Philosophy
My Account. 0 items in cart | Total - $0.00. Share This. Text Size A A. Product Finder ... utopian minorities as the only ones concerned with issues of animal ...